The Six Dangerous Fallacies Of Social Media

October 16th, 2008 by GCI Canada Staff

Ran across this post by Jason Baer (hat tip: Larissa Fair). Apart from the always-useful “scowling Pulp Fiction-style monkey with a gun” photo, Baer dissects some misconceptions that people have about social media, how to do it and what can be achieved.

To save space, I’ll just list his top six picks (all FALSE in Baer’s opinion) and answer on my own.

1. Social Media is Inexpensive — FALSE
2. Social Media is Fast — TRUE
3. Social Media is “Viral Marketing” — FALSE
4. Social Media results can’t be measured — TRUE
5. Social Media is Optional — FALSE
6. Social media is Hard — FALSE

For (2) I would argue that, depending on how niche the community is that you’re trying to engage, good results can be achieved in days, if not hours. For (4) I would argue that (not from a technical, software-monitoring option) social media results can’t really be measured. Baer does concede that to a point: “Can those results be tied back directly to sales, and therefore ROI? Probably not yet …” [I still prefer the term ROE — Return On Engagement.]

I think that the dangerous part of social media is that it is becoming a catch-all phrase; something that people who don’t really understand it think that it can guarantee results, cheaply, without much effort and because … well … “everyone else is doing it, right?”

~ John Carson, Senior Digital Media Specialist, GCI Canada

4 Responses to “The Six Dangerous Fallacies Of Social Media”

  1. Jason Baer Says:

    John -

    I absolutely agree with your point about the “catch-all” phrase and the terminology. It’s really a mess. To me, social media is much more of a loyalty and retention tool than it is an acquisition tool. Thus, is it really marketing at all? Isn’t it in many cases closer to customer service?

    Peter Kim has a good post recently on this issue.
    http://www.socialmediatoday.com/SMC/51519

    I’m formulating one as well. We need to get the taxonomy straight. It seems to be a digital marketing problem that frequently occurs. There’s still a lot of confusion about SEO vs. SEM vs. PPC vs. paid search vs. organic search vs. natural search etc.

    At least people know what “radio” means!

    Thanks much for the link and the thoughts.

    Jason Baer
    Convince and Convert

  2. GCI Canada Staff Says:

    You too JB!

    ~ JC.

  3. Hey OKC. Coming to the 10/30 OpenBeta? | StopDoingNothing! Says:

    […] The Six Dangerous Fallacies Of Social Media […]

  4. online digital photo printing in canada | Printing & Publishing - Printing Products, Printing Machinery Exporters, DVD Movie Exporters and more Says:

    […] The Six Dangerous Fallacies Of Social Media Apart from the always-useful “scowling Pulp Fiction-style monkey with a gun” photo, Baer dissects some misconceptions that people have about social media, how to do it and what can be achieved. To save space, I’ll just list his top six … […]

Leave a Reply